A feminist by any other name?

18 Sep

As if the term “feminist” wasn’t tricky enough in our daily lives (not tricky bad, just tricky complicated), trying to figure how, when, where, and for whom to use it when writing about the past is exponentially more so.   There are, of course, those easy cases in which women (and men, too) claimed the identity proudly. But what about all of the cases in which individuals lived their lives in feminist ways, or when groups act collectively to improve the lives of women, but did not publicly claim the title?  Perhaps they didn’t identify with the term, perhaps they weren’t familiar with it, or perhaps the term wasn’t available to them.  Regardless the reason, how do we discuss and explain their history?

On October 15th I am presenting a paper at the Western Historical Association about the Daughter’s of Bilitis (DOB), a lesbian group founded in 1955.  The eight founders initially envisioned a social group that would create a space for lesbian friendship during an oppressive social climate.  Within a year, a few of the original members and several new ones set out to improve the lives of lesbians by creating a publication (The Ladder), holding informational sessions (such as what to do when arrested at a gay bar), and evaluating the medical literature that defined them as deviants.  Many members would come to publicly identify as feminists and join feminist organizations as women’s liberation exploded onto the scene at the end of the 1960s.  They claimed no such identity, however, for most of the organizations first ten years.

My closest colleagues know I have been preoccupied for some time with DOB (as well as other public lesbians in the decades preceding Stonewall) and what appear to be actions, ideas, and sentiments that are “feministesque”.  Or at least, the seem to be feminist to me.   They maintained the significance of woman only space.  They asserted the need for fair employment and wages.  They debated the ways in which their experience of homosexuality was gendered.  They responded to limitations, inequalities, and dangers as gay women.   Do I call them feminists?  Do I call their work feminist in nature?  Do I describe them as “protofeminist?”   Is an activist for women’s rights by any other name still a feminist?

How do you define and use identity categories and terms in your work?  How do you define feminist pasts?  How do you use the term in your scholarship?

Advertisements

2 Responses to “A feminist by any other name?”

  1. Zoe Nicholson September 19, 2011 at 12:31 am #

    better not call them feminists. you gonna get slapped! 😉 I love that I can say such a thing. Purple balloons and lavender tees – the word is gay if integrated, lesbian if not. It seemed so easy then, no one got mad – just corrected wrong usage.

    it makes me think of the opening of Judy Chicago’s Dinner Party and the only living woman in the art was Georgia O’Keefe. GO was invited to be THE guest of honor. She declined and said that her art was not vaginas. Right.

    I am a proud feminist but you won’t find that on my card. I changed it to Equality Activist when Sotamayer was asked if she would vote on the Supreme Court as a woman or as a Latina. Right. Who ya gonna leave behind?

  2. Chris Deutsch September 25, 2011 at 6:42 pm #

    Good luck with the paper!

    My approach is to address my question. If that fails me, I call a group or person by the term they used unless I am asking if they are “proto,” “pre,” or “post.” Right now I am working with professional anticommunist women and their religion. I can safely call many of them Christian but for those that seem for instance Calvanist, do I use that term? I might highlight the similiarities but I never know the exact line either. Appropriately, UCLA is hosting a conference on the generation that become Mexican-American.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: